French Ham and Comté Pasta Gratin

Every French kid grows up on this. Gratin de pâtes au jambon is the Tuesday night dinner of half the country, and nobody ever gets sick of it.

It is pasta, ham and a creamy cheese sauce, baked until the top goes crisp and golden. That is the whole idea.

I used pipette pasta this time, those little curved hollow tubes. The sauce gets right inside them, so every bite is loaded instead of just coated.

When it comes out of the oven it is bubbling around the edges and the panko on top has gone the colour of toast. You need to wait five minutes before serving, and those five minutes are hard.

Close-up of the pipette pasta dry in a bowl, showing the hollow curved shape

 

What Makes This Different to Mac and Cheese

Americans build mac and cheese on cheddar. The French build this on a proper béchamel and a mountain cheese, and the result is smoother and much less greasy.

Cheddar is a young, acidic cheese with loose protein structure. Heat it in a sauce and it tends to split, which is why so many baked pastas end up with a layer of orange oil sitting on top.

The word gratin comes from the old French verb gratter, meaning to scrape. The name was never about the sauce underneath. It was about the crust you scrape off the sides of the dish, which was always the best bit.

Béchamel itself is named after Louis de Béchameil, a financier and steward in the court of Louis XIV. He almost certainly never made it. A court cook flattered him with the name and it stuck for 350 years.

Whisking the warm milk into the butter and flour roux in the saucepan, sauce turning smooth

 

Why Comté Is the Whole Dish

Comté comes from the Jura, up against the Swiss border, and it is the most produced AOP cheese in France. It has had protected status since 1958, which makes it one of the first French cheeses to get it.

It is made only from the milk of Montbéliarde and French Simmental cows, and the herds have to be grazed on pasture, not fed silage. That restriction is the reason the flavour shifts with the seasons.

One wheel weighs around 40kg and takes roughly 450 litres of milk to make. No single small farm has that much milk in a day, which is why the farmers have pooled it in village co-ops called fruitières since the Middle Ages.

Minimum ageing is four months, but most of the good stuff sits for 12 to 18 months and some goes well past two years. Older wheels develop crunchy little white crystals of tyrosine, an amino acid that has crystallised out of the protein as it breaks down.

In a sauce it melts clean and tastes nutty and faintly sweet, almost like brown butter and hazelnut. It does all the heavy lifting here, so buy a wedge and grate it yourself.

Grating the wedge of Comté, pile of golden shreds building up

 

Cooking Tips

Pull the pasta two minutes before the packet time. Less than al dente, properly firm. It keeps cooking in the oven and drinks up sauce while it does.

Warm the milk before it goes into the roux. Cold milk hitting hot flour and butter is how you get lumps.

Cook the flour and butter for a minute or two before any milk goes in. Raw flour tastes like raw flour and no amount of cheese hides it.

Keep the sauce looser than you think it needs to be. The pasta will thicken it in the oven, and a sauce that is already stiff in the pan turns to paste by the time it bakes.

Take the pan off the heat before the Comté goes in. Boiling cheese squeezes the fat out of it and the sauce turns oily and stringy.

Grate the cheese yourself. Pre-grated bags are dusted with potato starch or cellulose to stop clumping, and that coating makes a gritty sauce.

Toss the panko in melted butter before it goes on top. Dry crumbs scorch in patches, buttered crumbs go evenly golden.

Rest it for five minutes out of the oven. The sauce sets just enough to hold its shape on the spoon instead of running across the plate.

The buttered panko being scattered over the top of the dish before baking

 

Ingredient Swaps

No Comté? Gruyère is the closest swap, then Beaufort or Emmental. All three are alpine cheeses with the same long ageing and good melting behaviour.

Any small pasta works if you cannot find pipette. Elbow macaroni, conchiglie, casarecce, anything with a hollow or a curl that traps sauce.

Swap the ham for shredded leftover roast chicken, or for lardons fried until crisp. Smoked ham works too, just use a bit less because it is louder.

Leave the ham out entirely and it is still a proper dish. Add sautéed mushrooms or a handful of wilted spinach, squeezed dry, in its place.

No panko? Stale sourdough blitzed in a food processor is better than shop-bought dried crumbs. Coarser, so it stays crunchier.

Common Mistakes

Cooking the pasta to al dente or beyond. That is the mistake that ruins this dish, and it is the easiest one to make out of habit.

Letting the roux brown. A blond roux is fine for a gravy, but here it muddies the colour and the flavour of a white sauce.

Adding the cheese over the heat. Melt it in off the burner with the residual warmth of the sauce.

Making the sauce too thick. If it holds a trail from the whisk like wallpaper paste, thin it with a splash more warm milk before the pasta goes anywhere near it.

Going heavy on the nutmeg. An eighth of a teaspoon is a background note. Any more and the whole dish tastes like Christmas.

Baking it too long chasing more colour. Twenty-five minutes at 400°F / 200°C is plenty, and past that the sauce starts to break.

The sauce coating the back of a spoon, showing the correct loose consistency

 

What to Serve With It

It is rich, so it wants something sharp beside it. A green salad with a mustardy vinaigrette is what you would get in France and it is still the right answer.

Cornichons or pickled onions on the side work beautifully. The acid cuts straight through the cream.

To drink, a dry white from the Jura if you can find one, which is the local pairing. A simple Chardonnay does the job otherwise.

Storage and Reheating

Covered in the fridge it keeps for three days. The pasta keeps absorbing sauce, so it firms up overnight.

Reheat it in the oven at 350°F / 180°C for 15 to 20 minutes, covered with foil for the first 10. Add a splash of milk over the top first to loosen it back up.

The microwave works for a single portion but you lose the crisp top. Uncovered under a hot grill for a minute brings some of it back.

You can freeze it, assembled and unbaked, for up to two months. Thaw it overnight in the fridge and add about 10 minutes to the bake.

 

FAQs

Can I make this ahead of time?
Yes. Assemble it, leave the buttered panko off, and keep it covered in the fridge for up to a day. Add the topping just before it goes in the oven, and give it an extra five minutes to heat through.

 

Why did my sauce go grainy?
Almost always too much heat once the cheese was in, or pre-grated cheese with anti-caking starch on it. Take the pan off the burner before the Comté goes in and grate it yourself.

 

What is pipette pasta?
Small curved hollow tubes, sometimes sold as pipe rigate or chifferi. The bend traps sauce inside, which is exactly what you want in a gratin. Elbow macaroni is the easy substitute.

 

Folding the drained pasta through the cheese sauce and ham in the baking dish]

 

Can I use a different cheese?
Gruyère, Beaufort or Emmental all work. Avoid cheddar if you want the French version, because it splits more easily and takes the dish in a completely different direction.

 

Do I need the mustard?
It is not there to taste of mustard. Dijon sharpens the dairy and keeps the sauce from tasting flat, and you would miss it more than you expect if you left it out.

 

Why is my gratin dry?
The sauce was too thick going in, or it was baked too long. Keep the sauce loose, and pull the dish as soon as it is bubbling at the edges and golden on top.

 

Can I double it?
Yes, and it bakes well in a large dish for a crowd. Keep the depth similar rather than piling it deeper, otherwise the middle is still cool when the top is done.

 

The baked gratin straight out of the oven, golden crust, bubbling at the edges, spoon lifted out

 

Simple Food, Properly Done

There is nothing clever about this dish. A roux, a good cheese, some ham and pasta that was pulled from the water early.

That is the thing about French home cooking. The technique is quiet, and the result tastes like somebody cared.

Make it on a cold night with a sharp salad beside it. There will be no leftovers.